Born in December 1984, Rachael DelTondo grew up in the United States in the tight-knit community of Aliquippa, Pennsylvania. Her parents, Lisa and Joe DelTondo, represented the quintessential American couple. Aliquippa, a town once thriving due to a bustling steel mill, faced hard times when the mill shut down, leaving its population of 9,000 to grapple with economic challenges.
Despite these hardships, Rachael DelTondo blossomed into a sociable and beautiful young woman. By 2010, her striking appearance and charisma attracted admirers from prominent local families.
A Promising Romance
Rachael’s love story with Frank Catroppa, a local businessman, began as a childhood connection rekindled in adulthood. Their romance seemed like a fairytale. Frank proposed to Rachael during a romantic trip to Paris, giving her an engagement ring that symbolized a bright future. At the time, Rachael DelTondo was a full-time teacher at Pennsylvania Charter School, excited to embark on this new chapter.
However, cracks appeared in their relationship. Frank’s family demanded a prenuptial agreement, a move that deeply offended Rachael’s mother, Lisa. This conflict escalated, ultimately leading to the wedding’s cancellation. Yet, the couple continued their relationship in secret, despite Lisa’s disapproval.
In February 2016, their already strained relationship took a shocking turn. During Super Bowl weekend, while Frank was away, Rachael was discovered in a parked car with a 17-year-old former student, Sheldon Jeter Jr.. The police found the car’s windows fogged and the engine off. Rachael claimed they were discussing the teenager’s family issues in a private location. Despite her plea to keep the incident off the record, whispers spread through Aliquippa.
Adding to her stress, Rachael DelTondo and her family had already spent thousands on wedding preparations. Lisa, determined to recover some of the expenses, enlisted the help of a local CBS reporter, Marty Griffin, to secure a refund for Rachael’s $10,000 wedding dress. The public nature of the dispute added to Rachael’s embarrassment.
Meanwhile, her social circle began to fracture. In October 2017, Rachael DelTondo had a heated argument with her best friend, Jane Glovan, during a party. Jane accused Rachael of drug use, which she denied. The confrontation escalated, and Jane retaliated by revealing details of Rachael’s encounter with Sheldon to Frank.
Read more Jamie Bolin: The Girl Who Touched So Many Hearts
The Fallout
Frank’s father, a retired police officer, used his connections to acquire a police report on the Super Bowl weekend incident. Although the report had initially not been documented, Frank pressured the officers to draft one retroactively. The details contradicted Rachael’s claims, stating that the car had been parked in a secluded area at 2 AM, not at a convenience store at 11 PM as Rachael DelTondo alleged.
The report was swiftly distributed, seemingly aimed at damaging Rachael’s reputation. Copies were sent to her school, city officials, and local media outlets, casting a shadow over her professional and personal life. The inclusion of Sheldon Jeter Jr.’s name, a celebrated athlete in Aliquippa, only intensified the public’s interest in the scandal.
On the night Rachael DelTondo was discovered in a parked car with Sheldon Jeter Jr., the fallout began immediately. The officers, after escorting Sheldon home, unknowingly set the stage for events that would haunt Rachael long after. She was suspended from her teaching position, and an investigation launched to determine if she had engaged in inappropriate behavior with a minor.
It was soon revealed that Rachael DelTondo had known Sheldon since his elementary school days, where she had once been his teacher. This connection fueled rumors of an on-and-off relationship, casting a shadow over her character. In Aliquippa, a town where gossip spread like wildfire, Rachael found herself increasingly ostracized.
A Scandal Deepens
By December 2017, whispers of impropriety turned into a full-blown controversy. The Pennsylvania State Police intervened, investigating the Aliquippa Police Department after it was revealed that the leaked police report about Rachael’s 2016 incident originated from within the department itself. The breach was severe enough that the department temporarily lost access to state databases, further tarnishing its reputation.
In March 2018, the investigation escalated as state police raided the Aliquippa municipal building, seizing hard drives and documents. The details of the grand jury investigation remained undisclosed, but it signaled that deeper issues were at play.
The Day of Tragedy
On Mother’s Day, May 13, 2018, Rachael DelTondo, now unemployed, decided to spend the evening with friends. Around 8 PM, she accepted an invitation from a teenage friend, the daughter of Aliquippa Police Sergeant Kenneth Watkins, to go out for ice cream. Their evening seemed ordinary—stopping at a convenience store, visiting another friend, and returning to Rachael’s house so she could change clothes.
At 10:44 PM, Rachael was dropped off outside her parents’ home. Just minutes later, at 10:48 PM, gunshots shattered the quiet night. Rachael, 33 years old, was fatally shot in front of her house. The attack was sudden, leaving her family and the entire Aliquippa community in shock.
Authorities moved quickly to piece together Rachael’s final hours. Tyrie Jeter, Sheldon’s brother, confirmed their ice cream trip and the timing of Rachael’s drop-off. Meanwhile, Sergeant Watkins was placed on paid administrative leave due to his daughter’s involvement as a witness.
Phone records and text messages became a key focus. Investigators uncovered that Watkins’ daughter had messaged Rachael DelTondo at 10:41 PM, inviting her for a walk. Rachael’s reply was skeptical, even joking. Ten minutes later, the teenager texted again, saying she was on her way. At 11:07 PM, she called Rachael, but it was already too late.
Tyrie allowed police to inspect his phone, where they found messages exchanged with his brother Sheldon. However, these texts were deemed inconsequential. On May 14, investigators interviewed Sheldon, whose unemotional reaction to Rachael’s death raised eyebrows. He claimed to have seen Rachael DelTondo earlier that day at a convenience store with Watkins’ daughter, where she mentioned her plans to get ice cream.
Read more Adrian Gonzalez: A Shocking Story of Child-on-Child Murder
Suspicions and Theories
Believing the murder to be a crime of passion, investigators focused on those closest to Rachael. The district attorney stated that the evidence suggested Rachael likely knew her killer. Sheldon Jeter became a person of interest due to his history with Rachael DelTondo and the possibility of a romantic motive. Search warrants were executed for Sheldon’s home and phone, but no evidence linked him to the crime.
Sheldon’s attorney dismissed the theory of jealousy, pointing out that Sheldon had tolerated Rachael’s complicated relationships in the past without issue. He argued that his client had no reason to harm her.
Rachael’s ex-fiancé, Frank Catroppa, also came under scrutiny. Though their relationship had ended, Frank’s knowledge of Rachael’s personal life seemed unusually detailed. The timing of his obtaining the police report about Rachael’s 2016 incident raised suspicions. Many speculated that the report’s rapid leak was an act of revenge, fueled by jealousy.
Rachael’s parents, Lisa and Joe DelTondo, strongly believed that her ex-fiancé, Frank Catroppa, played a role in the leak of the damaging police report. Frank, however, vehemently denied any involvement. His attorney presented a solid alibi for the night of Rachael’s murder, supported by surveillance footage showing Frank 30 miles away at the time of the shooting. Frank also fully cooperated with the investigation, but the tension between him and the DelTondo family remained palpable.
Fears of Retaliation
In the months leading up to her death, Rachael confided in her mother about growing fears for her safety. She revealed she was assisting the Pennsylvania State Police in an investigation into corruption within the Aliquippa Police Department. Rachael believed she was being followed by local police and had even received death threats, shattering her trust in the authorities.
Lisa questioned the integrity of the murder investigation, citing the Aliquippa Police Department’s history of internal issues. These concerns gained traction as a series of shocking revelations about the department emerged.
The investigation into Rachael DelTondo’s murder coincided with an ongoing probe into allegations that the Aliquippa Police Department had been inflating overtime hours for soon-to-retire officers to increase their pensions. While the city attorney quickly denied any connection between Rachael’s murder and the pension scandal, the situation painted a picture of a department mired in controversy.
The scandal had immediate consequences. The Police Chief was placed on paid leave just weeks after Rachael’s murder. Allegations also surfaced against other high-ranking officers, including the Deputy Chief, who was suspended after being accused of sending sexually explicit material to a minor. The victim was reportedly a friend of Rachael’s, further complicating the case.
Sergeant Kenneth Watkins, whose daughter Lauren had been with Rachael DelTondo on the night of her murder, was also suspended with pay. The proximity of personal and professional ties cast a shadow over the investigation and raised significant conflict-of-interest concerns.
Read more The Tragic Case of 10-Year-Old Jessica Ridgeway
A Tangle of Leads and Allegations
Amid this chaos, a letter surfaced from a prison inmate accusing an Aliquippa police officer of Rachael’s murder. However, the police neither confirmed the letter’s authenticity nor disclosed its contents, leaving yet another unanswered question.
Recognizing the compromised nature of the investigation, the interim police chief transferred Rachael’s case to the Beaver County District Attorney’s Office, aiming to restore public confidence. However, the delayed action meant that critical leads may have been lost in the case’s early days.
Attorneys for both Frank and Sheldon Jeter Jr., a longtime person of interest in Rachael’s murder, pointed to the 2016 police encounter between Rachael DelTondo and Sheldon as a glaring example of the Aliquippa Police Department’s failings. They argued that the incident should have been reported to the state child abuse hotline as a potential case of sexual misconduct, but no such report was ever filed. This oversight highlighted why the department’s involvement in Rachael DelTondo’s murder investigation was highly problematic.
Two years after Rachael DelTondo’s death, Sheldon Jeter Jr. was convicted in an unrelated case. The murder of Tyric Pugh, a local man found shot to death, led to Sheldon’s life sentence. Despite his conviction, no concrete evidence ever tied him to Rachael’s murder.
Lisa DelTondo described the profound impact of Rachael’s death on her family. She admitted that every morning she woke up hoping it had all been a nightmare, only to face the heartbreaking reality of her daughter’s absence. Despite the pain, Lisa and Joe continue to live in Aliquippa, clinging to the hope that justice will one day prevail.
An Open Case, A Lingering Mystery
Rachael DelTondo’s murder remains an unsolved mystery, clouded by allegations of corruption, personal vendettas, and mismanagement. Her tragic story stands as a stark reminder of the deep flaws within the systems meant to protect and serve.
As her family waits for answers, the questions surrounding Rachael’s final days remain haunting. Who was responsible for her death? And will the tangled web of secrets ever unravel to reveal the truth? Until then, Rachael DelTondo’s case remains a chilling example of injustice.
