Margaret Sumney entered the world on June 28, 1958, in Pennsylvania. From the earliest years of her life, movement and music surrounded her. Her family owned a local dance studio that became a central part of her identity. She wasn’t just a spectator—Margaret danced, taught, and eventually choreographed entire productions. The studio became a cultural anchor in their town, especially during the holiday season, when her annual Christmas performances brought the community together.
More than an instructor, Margaret was known for her elegance and radiant energy. She exuded warmth, always dressed with care, and left lasting impressions wherever she went.
Margaret married John Joseph Teary in her early adult years. The marriage, however, offered little stability. John was emotionally distant and unreliable, leaving Margaret to shoulder the responsibilities of both parenting and providing. After the divorce, she raised her two daughters, Helen and Peg, alone. With no financial or emotional support from their father, Margaret managed everything—from studio operations to homework and discipline—with quiet strength.
A Second Chance at Love For Margaret Sumney
In 1986, Margaret met David Lee Sumney, a dentist with a polished background and a degree from Harvard. He was charming, successful, and attentive—qualities Margaret hadn’t experienced in a partner before. They married and soon settled into a comfortable life in Pennsylvania. Three years later, their son, David Lee Sumney Jr., was born. David Sr. played an involved role in his son’s early life and became a father figure to Margaret’s daughters as well.
From the outside, they appeared to be a happy, blended family with strong foundations. But behind closed doors, cracks were forming.
David Jr. was raised in a world without boundaries. His every desire was quickly fulfilled—gifts, trips, attention. He learned early that asking wasn’t necessary when demanding got faster results. Over time, he developed manipulative habits, turning every situation to his advantage. Gratitude and accountability were foreign concepts to him.
An early sign of deeper issues came when David Jr. killed a bird in the backyard—not by accident, but with intention. When Margaret Sumney saw the lack of remorse in her son’s eyes, she joked to relatives that he acted like a future criminal. But the humor masked real fear. Her son lacked empathy, and it was getting worse.
Read more Brittany Steier: A Life Stolen by the One She Trusted
Collapse of the Foundation
By 2001, Margaret’s marriage had quietly disintegrated. Though the divorce wasn’t hostile, it marked a sharp decline in the family’s stability. Financial strain followed. The dance studio—Margaret’s lifelong passion and community gift—closed its doors. She took a retail job just to make ends meet.
David Jr., meanwhile, remained unchanged. He still expected—and often received—preferential treatment. His father, despite being separated from Margaret Sumney, continued to support his son financially, enabling his behavior and hoping to maintain a fragile connection.
Even living in separate homes, Margaret Sumney and David Sr. were locked in a toxic cycle: appeasing their son in an attempt to avoid conflict.
Over the years, David Jr. manipulated both parents with growing ease. He moved between their homes like a monarch visiting subjects, using affection as currency and rage as a weapon. Margaret and David Sr. grew accustomed to managing his emotions rather than addressing his behavior.
In 2008, David Jr. enrolled in George Washington University to study mathematics. It was a turning point, or so his parents believed. The expenses were overwhelming, but they clung to hope that education might steer him in a healthier direction.
Unanswered Questions
In 2010, Margaret made an unplanned trip to Washington, D.C., to see her son. What followed was shrouded in confusion and concern. She ended up hospitalized, having reportedly fallen and injured her head. Margaret Sumney told Helen that David Jr. had tried to hurt himself with a knife, but her account was evasive and inconsistent.
When Helen arrived, she found both her mother and brother admitted to the hospital—oddly, in separate rooms. The medical staff offered little clarity, and no formal investigation ever followed. The incident faded into silence, like so many warning signs before it.
But for Margaret’s daughters, the doubts remained. And so did the fear.
Not long after the troubling events in D.C., David Jr.’s time at George Washington University came to an abrupt end. The official reason: repeated infractions. He had skipped classes, engaged in volatile altercations, and repeatedly violated campus rules. The expulsion shattered his parents. After years of emotional sacrifice and financial strain, this marked yet another devastating blow.
Returning to Pennsylvania, David Jr. bounced between the homes of his mother and father. He remained idle, entitled, and unchanged.
A Violent Breaking Point
By July 2015, David Jr. was 26—unemployed, disconnected from reality, and entirely dependent on his parents. That summer, after his father refused to give him money for a vacation, David Jr.’s anger exploded into violence.
He assaulted David Sr. in a shocking outburst that neighbors heard from the street. When police arrived, they found Jr. on top of his father, delivering a relentless beating. David Sr. suffered catastrophic injuries: brain bleeding, spinal trauma, and permanent damage that left him unable to care for himself. He was transferred to a long-term care facility.
Jr. was arrested on the spot, but only charged with aggravated assault. Despite the brutal nature of the attack, he was quickly released after posting bond. The man he nearly killed would never speak for himself again—and Jr. faced minimal consequences.
A Fictional Redemption
After the attack, Jr. began telling others that he had joined the U.S. Navy. The claim seemed out of place, but Margaret Sumney, desperate for hope, clung to it. The image of her troubled son finding purpose and discipline in military service offered a fragile thread of comfort.
But it was all a lie. Jr. showed no proof of enlistment, no uniform, no paperwork. Every question was met with vagueness. No records existed—he had never served in any military branch.
In the months that followed, David Jr. transformed himself physically. He dedicated himself to extreme bodybuilding, developing an imposing, muscular frame. Standing nearly six-and-a-half feet tall and heavily built, his appearance became as intimidating as his behavior.
His aggression escalated alongside his physical strength. Conversations grew tense. Threats—both subtle and overt—became part of daily life. He controlled his environment through fear, and Margaret Sumney, exhausted by years of turmoil, kept holding onto the son she once knew, even as he became someone unrecognizable.
The Midnight Attack
In November 2016, Margaret’s home became the scene of yet another nightmare. One night, while she was asleep, David Jr., drunk and seething, entered her room and began strangling her. The attack was wordless and swift. Overpowered by his strength, Margaret Sumney struggled to breathe.
Somehow, she managed to break free and scream. Jr. retreated without explanation and went back to bed. Margaret Sumney called the police.
When officers arrived, they found her bruised, with visible marks around her neck and ribs. Jr., meanwhile, was asleep, reeking of alcohol. He claimed to have used a “Marine Corps technique”—a statement that reignited questions about his military claims.
He was arrested and charged with domestic violence. But once again, Margaret Sumney intervened.
Fearing felony charges might destroy whatever future her son still had, Margaret pleaded with prosecutors to lessen the charges. She argued that he had been intoxicated, not malicious. She repeated the story of his supposed military background, presenting it as evidence of his potential to reform.
The court agreed to her appeal. The felony was reduced to a lesser charge. But during the proceedings, an official background check revealed the truth: David Jr. had never served in any branch of the military. His story had been a complete fabrication.
Despite the revelation, Margaret Sumney remained convinced he could still change.
First Real Consequence
David Jr. was sentenced to 16 months—the first substantial consequence he had ever faced. In jail, he recast his narrative. He claimed addiction, not violence, was the root of his problems. He portrayed himself as a man battling inner demons fueled by alcohol, not someone shaped by years of cruelty and manipulation.
The strategy worked. Officials bought the story. And once again, David Jr. walked a path shaped not by accountability—but by manipulation.
After the violent assault on his mother, David Jr. narrowly avoided prison once again. A social worker, convinced that treatment was the answer, advocated for rehabilitation over incarceration. The court agreed.
David Jr. was transferred to a Pennsylvania recovery facility, where he began attending therapy and group sessions under structured supervision. Margaret Sumney remained a constant presence—bringing supplies, offering encouragement, and continuing to believe her son could be saved. For her, the rehabilitation center offered something she hadn’t felt in years: hope.
When David Jr. completed the program, he transitioned into a halfway house and soon secured employment. Reports from the facility described him as cooperative and compliant—a young man appearing to turn his life around. To those watching from the outside, it looked like a redemption arc.
But appearances were deceiving.
Read more Bree Kuhn’s Final Call: Self-Defense or Cold Blood?
The Mask Slips Again
Beneath the polished image of reform, David Jr. remained unchanged. His charm was performative. He never admitted fault for the pain he had caused, never expressed remorse for the attack on his father, and never truly took ownership of his actions.
By 2018, the facade began to crack—though not fast enough to raise alarms. That August, David Lee Sumney Sr. passed away at the age of 74 in a Pennsylvania nursing facility. The official cause: age-related complications. But those closest to the family knew better.
His health had steadily deteriorated since 2015, when his son’s assault left him with brain damage, spinal injuries, and profound physical disability. Once independent and active, David Sr. had been robbed of his dignity. Though no legal action followed his death, the impact of that beating was etched into every moment of his final years.
At the funeral, Margaret Sumney maintained her composure. She did not speak out against her son—not even in whispers. Her silence created deep tension among relatives who could not reconcile her loyalty with the undeniable consequences of Jr.’s actions.
A Dangerous Pattern Resurfaces
In 2019, David Jr. began a new relationship through a dating app. The woman, who later chose anonymity to protect herself, moved in with him quickly. At first, he presented himself as a reformed man—caring, charismatic, and attentive.
That illusion faded fast.
Controlling behaviors emerged. He tracked her whereabouts, enforced strict rules, and monitored her communication. She also noticed he was using checks signed in Margaret’s name. He claimed to be managing his mother’s finances due to her alleged mental health struggles—though there was no legal power of attorney or documentation to support it. When confronted, he blamed paperwork delays.
As the relationship spiraled and the woman planned to leave, David Jr. became unhinged. He manipulated her into meeting him at a hotel in Atlantic City. Once there, he trapped her.
For days, she was beaten and strangled unconscious more than once. She had no access to outside help. At one point, Jr. thought he had killed her and fled. She lay unmoving, injured and alone. Only a vigilant hotel staff member—concerned about the extended “Do Not Disturb” sign—entered the room and found her still breathing.
Another System Failure
She survived. An arrest warrant for David Jr. was issued on July 16, 2019. But in a devastating clerical failure, it was never entered into the federal database. As a result, David Jr. returned to Pennsylvania and moved freely, undetected.
He was arrested days later on unrelated charges—but with no record of the active warrant, he was released without consequence.
Once again, the system had failed. A brutal assault had gone unpunished. A woman had nearly died. And David Jr. was back on the streets, untouched by accountability.
The Final Silence
Weeks later, tragedy struck again. On September 1, 2019, Margaret’s brother, John, passed away. Family members attempted to notify Margaret Sumney and coordinate the funeral.
When phone calls went unanswered, one of Margaret’s sisters reached out to Helen, her eldest daughter. She, too, tried to reach Margaret Sumney—without success.
No one knew it yet, but something far more horrifying had already taken place. Margaret’s silence wasn’t grief—it was absence.
And this time, there would be no second chances.
An Unanswered Phone Call
On September 1, 2019, as the Sumney family mourned the passing of John—Margaret’s brother—relatives began coordinating the funeral. Naturally, they reached out to Margaret Sumney, but something felt off. Repeated phone calls from one of her sisters went unanswered.
Growing uneasy, the sister contacted Margaret’s eldest daughter, Helen. She, too, tried to call—again, no response.
By the next morning, September 2, worry had turned to dread.
Helen called once more. This time, her brother picked up.
A Chilling Response
David Jr. answered in a dull, detached voice. He said Margaret Sumney was sleeping and refused to wake her. His tone was cold, evasive, and devoid of emotion.
Alarm bells rang. The family wasted no time—they contacted local authorities in Pennsylvania and requested a welfare check.
Police arrived at the home and knocked. No answer. The windows were drawn, and silence blanketed the property. Minutes later, officers forced entry.
What they found was nothing short of nightmarish.
The odor hit them first—foul, pungent, unmistakably death. Blood was visible in multiple rooms. Drag marks on the floors and stained towels pointed to a gruesome cleanup attempt.
Upstairs, the full horror revealed itself.
Margaret’s body lay in the bathtub. She had been dead for over 24 hours. Her injuries were extensive—blunt force trauma to the head and neck, lacerations, blood spattered across walls and floors. A sickle, stained with blood, was found in a hallway.
A revolver registered in Margaret’s name was missing. Only its empty ammunition box remained.
The scene was chaotic—but also calculated. The deliberate placement of evidence, the stages of cleanup, and the lack of panic suggested premeditation.
Read more Who Killed Juliana Redding? The DNA Mystery That Shook L.A.
The Hard Drive
In David Jr.’s belongings, investigators found a laptop and an external hard drive. What they discovered would haunt them.
There were 277 photos. Many depicted Margaret’s corpse, arranged in different positions. Some were selfies—David Jr. posing with his dead mother, wearing a blank or even smug expression. Lighting had been adjusted. Angles chosen carefully. This was not a moment of impulse—it was a ritual.
Timestamps confirmed the process spanned several hours.
Even more chilling was his internet history. He had searched how to remove blood from fabric and tile, how decomposition works, and which chemicals mask the smell of death. He researched mummification techniques.
This wasn’t panic. It was planning.
Investigators had no doubts about the killer. But they needed to catch him. They turned to the one person who might help: Helen.
Reluctantly, she agreed to set a trap. She invited David Jr. to attend their uncle’s funeral, knowing he might not resist.
He showed up.
Police were waiting.
Among his belongings were Margaret’s personal checks and jewelry. He was arrested on-site.
The Sentence
David Jr. was formally charged with third-degree murder, abuse of a corpse, theft, and related offenses. A psychiatric evaluation found him competent to stand trial.
In August 2022, he accepted a plea deal.
He admitted guilt and was sentenced to 20 to 40 years in prison. With time served, he could be eligible for parole in 2039, around his 50th birthday.
For Margaret’s family, the sentence felt like betrayal. The photographic evidence, the brutality, the manipulation—it all pointed to something far darker than third-degree murder. Her daughters and sisters spoke out publicly, criticizing the leniency of the plea.
In court, David Jr. offered a brief apology, claiming he didn’t understand how he could have done what he did.
The words meant nothing.
A Legacy of Silence and Warnings Ignored
Margaret’s story didn’t end in a moment of madness. It ended after years of denial, fear, and misplaced hope. Her death wasn’t random—it was the outcome of a life spent trying to save someone who had long since gone beyond saving.
She died at the hands of the son she never stopped protecting.
Within just two days, the family lost both John and Margaret Sumney. But the real loss had occurred years before—when David Jr. first began showing signs of violence that no one wanted to face.
Helen has severed all ties. Her brother now lives behind bars—a convicted killer. What remains is grief, anger, and the heavy burden of knowing it didn’t have to happen this way.
